Christian Catalini, a former team member of Meta’s Libra project, has expressed concerns that Stripe’s blockchain ambitions may compromise one of the core principles of the cryptocurrency movement: decentralization. Catalini believes that if Stripe’s blockchain efforts are commercially successful, it could mean that early crypto idealists will have to accept a future where the original ethos of decentralization is lost.
The Failure of Libra: A Cautionary Tale
Catalini reflects on the failure of Libra, stating that being too early to market can be just as detrimental as being wrong. He wrote, “When I look back on Libra, the StableCoin project I designed at Meta, I can confirm that we were not only early. We were also wrong, spectacularly wrong.” The failure of Libra can be attributed to several factors, including poor timing, “Silicon Valley hubris,” and aggressive marketing, which attracted unwanted attention and provided ammunition to opponents.
Corporate Blockchains and the Problem of Incentives
Catalini argues that the issue with corporate blockchains, such as Stripe’s, lies not in the code, but in the incentives. He explains that corporate blockchains often promise fairness but eventually succumb to the temptation to tilt the field in their favor after gaining significant market share. This is a fundamental economic truth that crypto aims to break, as it is designed to be permissionless and decentralized.
The Implications of Stripe’s Success
According to Catalini, if Stripe’s blockchain efforts are successful, it could signal that the crypto experiment was not a revolution, but a failed coup. This would mean that the market structure remains largely unchanged, with the same players controlling the market, despite the introduction of new backend technology. Catalini warns that this could lead to a more centralized reality, where the original dreamers of the crypto world may have to accept a more pragmatic, but less decentralized, future.
A Warning and a Call to Action
Catalini cautions that if the spirit of Libra is a warning of a fundamental truth – that every system is based on a fatal mistake with a single architect – then Stripe is not writing a new story, but rather an expensive sequel. He emphasizes the importance of preserving the decentralized nature of crypto and warns against the dangers of corporate blockchains compromising this principle.
For more information on this topic, visit https://cryptoslate.com/critics-argue-stripes-blockchain-ambitions-clashes-with-crypto-decentralization/
